Tags: #londonriots

Views: 122

Replies to This Discussion

. . .

 

My take on the London riots and the criticism of the role of media amid masses of citizen journalism :

 

That, again, we all seem overly fond of either/or arguments, rather than AND. For example, which is better, mainstream or citizen journalism? Social networks or newspapers?

For me, again, it's both, in answer to both questions.

Social networks gave me a vastly wider view of the riots and the background to them, than, say television networks like the BBC or ABC. 

Yet a lot of the "citizen journalism" on "social networks" led back to newspaper reports, notably the Guardian and the Independent. One of the most outstanding pieces pointed out that 333 people have died in police custody since 1998, as one of the underlying causes of anger. My jaw dropped. Later on, by day four, I found the best round up of Twitter comments on the London riots inside the (printed) pages of my daily newspaper, in this case, the New Zealand Herald, including this one, from a John Naughton :

" What the looting shows is that prosperity doesn't trickle down, but greed does. " 

And this one, in the same round up, from Aled Lewis :

" So can we conclude that having the most CCTV per square foot in the world is not an effective deterrent? "

Meanwhile, most reaction from TV news seemed to centre on a dazed and bloodied youth helped, then robbed, by others youths. Outrage? Sure, heaps. Context? Ah, nah. So is TV the lone write-off amidst the media estates, a worthy target of media criticism? 

Hardly. TV remains the the most immediate and popular of media forms, commanding bigger audiences than any combination of websites or newspapers, feeding eyeballs to other media much as radio did originally. Media critics need to get over their techno fetishism and start analysing the media mix, not the alleged winners and losers. 

. . .

I agree with your points. I think all channels of information correlated nicely with each other, though I still think that (and I come from social media, not media background, hence my approach probably) that mainstream media channels should start focussing on using their reach to help actively during crisis situations, not only analyse the events. 

Another interesting development is the fact that the Guardian was advising Twitter users on verification of information shared on social networks, which I think is a good move. I like to see all channels working together, let's just take it to the next level when we will not talk about the meaning of events while those evolve, but fist focus on help and solutions, later on evaluation. 

 

. . .

 

Sylwia, that's really interesting about the Guardian verifying Twitter feeds.One of the few initiatives to actually close the gap between what gets 'reported' by citizen media online and what gets reported offline by mainstream media. 

 

Seems to me that the online world has yet to assume as much importance among mainstream media as the usual avenues, press conferences, releases, publicity stunts or even full page ads. The Guardian Twitter hook up is a welcome development, and one that fits in with the correlation theme.

 

I agree it would be nice if the media were to focus on help and solutions, but there are also good reasons for a gap between observers and participants. What if the media suggests help that turns out to be wrong, even costs lives? Wouldn't the emergency response experts be a little alarmed at media leaping into their area of, erm, expertise? I get what you're trying to say, but I still have my reservations.

 

In the case of the riots, even if journalists focused on 'solutions' it might have the unintended effect of exposing counter-measures to rioters, thereby delaying resolution.

 

What emergency response people need most is information, and who better to supply that information than citizen journalists, people on the ground, thousands and thousands of them? And who better to double check that info than professional journalists? 

 

. . .

RSS

Latest Activity

Eliana van de Craats Lima joined Emma Brewin's group
Thumbnail

European Journalism Centre

News, resources and other updates from independent non-profit media organisation the European Journalism Centre.See More
2 hours ago
Eliana van de Craats Lima posted a discussion

Who Praised the Killing of an Innocent Baby in Jerusalem? The Palestinian Authority did it!

The Palestinian authority's advisor to President Mahmoud Abbas praised it and the Palestinian authority official website confirmed it as one can see from the video they uploaded on their page (see picture here below), with the title in Arabic saying, Jerusalem martyr Abdul Rhaman available here on the page of the Ministry of Information from the State of Palestine and…See More
9 hours ago
Eliana van de Craats Lima liked Ludwik Kowalski's discussion Conflicts in Russia
yesterday
Eliana van de Craats Lima posted a discussion

Let's not Boycott Peace by Abusing of Evil Propaganda in the Holly Land

As Franklin Roosevelt once said, "a nation does not have to be cruel to be tough" and that is the kind of message that should not be ignored by any politician or even terrorists that think they can build nations by emotionally threatening others to support or accept their demands.If Israel and its people, have already made a history of their own by planting gardens in the middle of the desert and reviving the Hebrew language while creating an advanced society that embraces science, religion and…See More
Friday
Eliana van de Craats Lima updated their profile
Wednesday
Ludwik Kowalski posted a discussion

Conflicts in Russia

Contemporary Russian Situation (10/17/2014) as described by BSN, an unnamed Russian author Translated by Ludwik Kowalski, Ph.D. http://csam.montclair.edu/~kowalski/life/intro.html    1) My translation of BSN's article is available online at: http://pages.csam.montclair.edu/~kowalski/bsn.html 2) Why did I translate this article? Because I know that the present…See More
Wednesday
Andrej Matisak posted a status
"Matisak's blog - What EP hearings told us about Juncker's Commission http://wp.me/pL6gx-1Ba"
Tuesday
Eugenio Hernandez updated their profile
Tuesday

© 2014   Created by Arne Grauls.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service